Holocaust Survivor Ella Blumenthal writes open letter to Simone Kriel in response to her antisemitic posts

Dear Simone,

I was so saddened to hear your comments.
Saddened, because I was about your age in 1945 when I was liberated from that pit of hell they called Bergen Belsen.
I had lost everything that I had ever had. I had lost almost everyone that I had ever loved..
I, like millions of others, had fallen victim to the vicious propaganda machine the Nazis relied on to advance their evil agenda.
Today they call propaganda “fake news" but it is the same thing.
And it is no less virulent or dangerous.
Simone, the link you saw was fake news.
It was a lie.
I know this because I lived the truth and I have carried it with me, in my heart, for more than 7 decades.
You see Simone, you can never forget what I saw, what I endured and what I survived.
I am sad because like me, you too were a victim of lies that seek to breed hatred and disgust .Lies that seek to divide us and make us fearful of one another.
And I am also angry. Not at you, but at those who still seek to make others the victims of their own fear.
Simone, I am 98 years old. And if I have learnt one thing, it is that to live as a victim of fear, is to live in pain.
I do not wish this on you anymore than I wish it on myself.

I would love to meet with you when circumstances permit.
Maybe I will tell you my story, and you will tell me yours.
I know we will learn that far more unites us, than divides us.
And maybe together, Simone, we will find a way to shine light into our fractured world.

I send you my love,

Ella Blumenthal.

Recent Articles

David Saks responds to Oscar van Heerden's antisemitic articles in News24

"Contrary to what is often claimed, no credible Jewish leader equate any criticism of the State of Israel with antisemitism, that is, hatred towards people of the Jewish faith and/or ethnicity. Pretty much without exception, all accept, as per the formulation of the International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance, that “criticism of Israel similar to that levelled against any other country cannot be regarded as antisemitic”.

​Wendy Kahn receives the Moses Award for leadership at this year’s Jewish Africa Conference

Wendy Kahn, National Director of the SAJBD, received the Moses Award for leadership at this year’s Jewish Africa Conference in Cape Town. Recognized for her tireless work, she’s been a driving force in safeguarding Jewish life within South Africa’s vibrant community.

In her heartfelt acceptance speech, Wendy highlighted the how inspired she is to see the formation of a united 'African Jewish' bloc, bringing together communities from across the continent. She also celebrated the resilience and courage of South African Jews.

​Wendy Kahn visits home of murdered friend Vivian Silver

It is 18 months since Hamas brutally murdered my friend Vivian Silver in her home in Kibbutz Be'eri on October 7, 2023.

I travelled to her home last month to pay tribute to her. For over a decade I worked with Vivian where she trained hundreds of South African government and civil society leaders in community development, agricultural development and cooperatives at NISPED and at her beloved Be'eri. As a founder of Women Wage Peace we brought a group of Muslim, Jewish and Christian women to SA in 2019 to engage with government, media and civil society. Vivian's dedication to peace building and human rights saw her driving cancer patients from Gaza to Israeli hospitals.